The state of gym operators in 2026
In 2026, gym operators are working to keep members coming back, use AI without losing the human touch and grow without weakening what works. Retention starts with repeatable habits, technology works best when it strengthens human coaching, expansion demands disciplined capital decisions, hybrid fitness can create shared purpose, and longevity requires programming for different stages of life.

Key takeaways
- Retention begins before cancellation risk appears, with early attendance, achievable wins, clear progress and relationships that make returning easier. 11:46
- AI earns its place when it reduces operational work, identifies useful moments for intervention and gives coaches more room for human connection. 7:06
- Our read: Prove the model at the locations you have before opening more, and ask what outside investors can contribute beyond capital.
- Hybrid fitness becomes more powerful when an event gives everyday training a shared purpose and members a reason to belong. 7:42
- Longevity programming needs to reflect real life stages, including older populations that conventional fitness environments and research can overlook. 12:02
Retention and the member habit
For operators, retention starts with a simple question: Are members actually coming in? Frequency drives both the results members experience and the value they attach to membership, according to Creegan. That reframes retention from a cancellation problem into a participation problem.
The best time to create stickiness is while the relationship is still forming, when operators can help a new member build a repeatable rhythm instead of waiting for disengagement to show up on a dashboard. 11:46
“The only metric that matters is really frequency.”
JJ Creegan, Fractional COO and CEO · 11:53
That rhythm cannot depend on members waking up motivated every day. Motivation fluctuates with sleep, stress, time and life circumstances, which means operators need an experience designed to survive ordinary disruptions, according to McKee. A smaller, achievable action can build confidence and positive feedback, giving members evidence that they can keep going.
The practical lesson is to design around the hard Tuesday, not the ideal version of the customer who appeared during onboarding. 5:55
“We need to design a useful version for the ordinary Tuesday when you're up against it with work or other commitments and your time is limited.”
Dr. Heather McKee, Motivation Science Advisor, Myzone · 6:02
Onboarding should turn that behavioral principle into something concrete. The early member journey needs to establish adherence, connection and an understanding of the programming, according to Hull. When members know why they are training, recognize familiar people and understand what comes next, attendance becomes less dependent on novelty.
Operators are not merely selling access to equipment or classes. They are creating an environment where showing up can become a normal part of the week. 13:08
The same logic changes how operators think about churn. Once a customer has decided to leave, the meaningful retention work has largely happened already, according to Creegan. Teams should focus on the experience, communication, values and operating systems that keep members engaged before that decision forms.
Technology can help spot behavior changes, but software does not replace the reasons somebody wants to return. As Creegan put it, “You can't ever save a cancellation. You can only prevent it.” 0:00
Go deeper: How gyms reduce member churn; Make exercise easier to repeat: Dr. Heather McKee.
Technology and the coaching relationship
AI should give operators leverage without stripping the experience of its human center. Foster said different gym models need different applications because a high-volume club, big box and boutique operate under different constraints. For boutiques, that can mean taking repetitive service and administrative work away from an owner who may also coach classes and know members personally.
The useful question is not whether a gym has AI. It is whether technology protects the work only people can do well. 7:06
That distinction becomes especially clear around member intervention. Foster said software can identify a member who attended an initial class but has not returned, then prompt the operator to reach out. The machine detects the moment while the coach supplies judgment, tone and relationship.
Used this way, automation does not have to create a colder experience. It can make human attention more timely by showing staff where that attention might matter. 7:06
“But where these products start to come in is you could get a notification saying that listen, someone came to their first class, they're still a member, but they haven't come back and it's been a week,” Foster said, 7:53
More data does not automatically make that relationship better. McKee said wearables primarily measure behavior and physiology, while adherence depends on the wider system surrounding that information. A dashboard becomes useful when somebody can understand what it means and connect it to a feasible next action.
For operators, this creates an opening for coaches to become interpreters rather than data collectors, translating signals into choices that fit the member's actual life. 18:01
“So like I think wearables can support behavior, but a device is primarily a measurement tool,” McKee said, 18:04
That is also where differentiation remains stubbornly human. Operators increasingly have access to similar customer records, visit histories and analytical tools, in Creegan’s view. The advantage comes from turning information into action in a way that reflects the brand's own experience and values.
Faster analysis matters, but identical tools can also produce increasingly similar insights. A coach who knows the member, understands context and acts at the right moment still creates something software alone cannot commoditize. 14:00
Go deeper: What AI can change in gym operations; Automate the handoff first: Karl Foster; Make athlete data useful: Spencer Tatum.
The next location and the deal behind it
Opening another location can look like the natural next step, but scale exposes whatever already exists in the product. Hull said operators need “a product that stands the test of time.” That puts programming, member experience and the operating model ahead of expansion for expansion's sake.
A concept that works because one charismatic founder holds everything together has different scaling requirements than a business whose systems consistently reproduce the experience. 2:25
“I think the second thing from all of that was I think you need to have a product that stands the test of time,” Hull said, 2:36
The founder's role must change along with the footprint. Hull said his own progression moved through training, group instruction, management, ownership, multi-unit operations and franchising. The larger point for operators is that the skills that create the first successful location are not automatically the skills that manage the next stage.
Growth requires deliberately handing responsibility to people who can preserve the product while the founder works on a different level of the business. 9:53
Capital introduces another layer of discipline. Coletta added that fundraising is deeply relationship-driven and that trusted introductions mattered throughout his experience raising money. For gym founders considering investors, strategic partners or larger transactions, the implication is straightforward: financing relationships should begin before money becomes urgent.
A rushed capital search leaves fewer options, while long-standing relationships give both sides more time to understand the business, the founder and the opportunity. 38:14
“And I'll just tell you what I've learned that raising capital is deeply relationship-driven,” Coletta said, 38:16
Money itself is only part of the deal. For Coletta, the priority was “value-added capital” beyond the check, while Bormel added that transaction diligence can span HR, IT, finance, tax and legal work. An operator preparing to scale, recapitalize or sell should therefore treat clean systems and documentation as operating infrastructure, not transaction cleanup.
Our read: Document unit economics, operating processes and who owns key decisions before investors start asking for them.
Deals can also reveal where larger companies and investors see opportunity. Bormel described that transactions send signals about what strategic buyers and private equity consider attractive enough to fund. That does not mean operators should chase every market signal.
It does mean they can study the capital environment while staying clear about their own model. The next location, partnership or transaction should strengthen the underlying business rather than become a substitute for building one. 19:43
Go deeper: What private equity looks for in fitness; Adapting a yoga studio to New York: Adam Shane; The fitness merger: Lanman and Roesch-Schlanderer.
Hybrid fitness programming and belonging
Hybrid fitness shows what happens when programming gains an external purpose. Magida described that members in his HYROX program found one another around a shared goal, then developed their own training relationships and group activity around it. That is more meaningful for an operator than simply adding another class format.
Events can give training a narrative: prepare together, test yourself and return with a new reason to keep working. 7:42
“And those people all found each other in this [HYROX] program because they're all training with this shared purpose and this shared goal,” Magida said, 8:12
Purpose does not require forcing every member into competition. Hull pointed out that Fitstop encourages people to train toward goals outside the gym as well as track their progress inside it. The operating opportunity is to connect everyday programming to something members can understand and anticipate.
A race may work for one customer while another simply wants measurable progress. In either case, training becomes easier to value when members know what their work is building toward. 12:20
Operators interested in HYROX should resist treating the trend as an equipment shopping list. Magida recommended testing member interest with real classes and coaching that reflects the sport. “Don't send out a survey, like go out and start doing some classes and things like that.”
The advice fits a broader operating principle: validate behavior before making a major commitment, and make sure the people leading a new offering understand what participants are preparing to do. 9:48
“Don't send out a survey, like go out and start doing some classes and things like that,” Magida said, 10:01
Hybrid programming also has to welcome people who do not yet see themselves as athletes. Magida pointed out that unfamiliar customers may arrive intimidated by exercising around a group, so coaches need to build comfort, confidence and competency. That connects directly back to retention.
A goal can create belonging only when the entry point feels achievable. The strongest community is not simply intense. It gives different members a legitimate place to begin and a path to improve together. 14:41
Go deeper: How gyms build a business around HYROX; A HYROX badge isn't a strategy: Eric O’Neil; Why HYROX is easy to share: Andrew Sugerman.
Training across life stages and recovery
The next expansion opportunity may be less about another modality and more about serving people the industry has not designed around well. King recalled that equipment, programming and physical environments often fail to account for older women. She also recalled that later life is a meaningful period for health, longevity and quality of life.
Operators can respond by examining access, coaching assumptions, equipment fit and social experience rather than treating older adults as an edge case. 12:02
“The equipment, the programming, even the environment is not built with this population in mind,” King said, 12:16
Social connection belongs in that design. King said gym visits can function as a social event for older members, particularly after retirement changes the rhythm of daily life. That makes community part of the service rather than an accidental side effect.
Recovery deserves the same broader view. Moyen pointed to studies in which nighttime temperature regulation improved heart rate and heart rate variability alongside sleep. For gym operators, the useful takeaway is not to become a sleep clinic.
It is to recognize that training sits inside a larger recovery system. Coaching conversations that ignore sleep and recovery risk treating performance as something produced exclusively during the workout. 2:10
“And we consistently see an improvement in heart rate, improvement in heart rate variability,” Moyen said, 2:22
At the other end of the data pipeline, operators should avoid turning recovery into another source of complexity. McKee stressed that people can become overly controlling about individual health variables and that habit research supports flexibility. That is especially relevant as gyms move further into longevity, wearables and recovery.
Good coaching can help members use information without letting a score dictate every decision, keeping the focus on sustainable behavior rather than perfect optimization. 29:27
Put these pieces together and the operator's job keeps getting broader, but the core remains surprisingly consistent. Creegan stressed that technology can increase efficiency while the customer experience still determines what people feel when they engage with the business. Better operators can use new tools, new formats and new health insights without losing sight of that foundation.
Build something people can return to, make progress visible, create meaningful relationships and let technology support the experience rather than become the experience. 12:46
Go deeper: How temperature affects sleep and training; What GLP-1s mean for gym membership; What changes women's sleep: Dr. Nicole Moyen; Why organs age differently: Paul Coletta; Train for a longer active life: David Harry Stewart.
Explore the Gym operators topic hub for more source-backed conversations.
Listen to the full conversation
Planet Fitness, UFIT & Orange Theory Insider JJ Creegan on What's Really Working in Fitness Right Now
Play the episodeFrequently asked questions
How can gyms improve member retention?
Gyms can improve retention by focusing on attendance habits before disengagement turns into cancellation. Creegan said frequency drives results and perceived value, while consistent visits also support word of mouth. Operators should make early participation easy, meaningful and socially connected instead of relying on last-minute cancellation saves. 11:46
How should gym operators use AI?
Gym operators should use AI to identify useful moments for action and remove repetitive work without outsourcing the relationship. Foster said technology can flag a new member who attended once but failed to return, giving staff a timely reason to make personal contact rather than automating every interaction. 7:06
How can gyms add HYROX or hybrid fitness programming?
Gyms can start small, test demand through actual coached sessions and expand once members show sustained interest. Magida reported that operators can begin with a dedicated HYROX class while keeping their existing programming intact. The key is building authentic coaching and structure before making a larger commitment to equipment or space. 12:41
How should gyms serve older women and longevity-focused members?
Gyms should examine programming, equipment and environment through the needs of older members instead of assuming an existing format fits everyone. King reported that these parts of the brick-and-mortar experience often were not built with older women in mind, creating an opportunity for more deliberate, accessible design. 12:02
Related insights
Quotes are lightly edited for clarity.
