New: The State of Fitness, Q2 2026. Get the free report
Capital and M&A

What private equity looks for in fitness

Private equity investors look for fitness businesses with repeatable economics, capable operators and a product customers have a reason to keep using. In fitness, that means looking beyond a hot modality or fast growth toward defensibility, repeatable economics, operator quality and a business model that can survive changing consumer behavior.

Jon Canarick
Jon Canarick, Managing Partner, North Castle Partners

Key takeaways

  • Durable fitness businesses survive shifts in modality, channel and consumer behavior without depending on one temporary growth spike. 13:02
  • Defensibility often comes from brand, community, customer relationships and execution rather than a workout concept competitors can imitate. 14:16
  • Operator fit matters because capital works best when investors share conviction in both the market thesis and management team. 36:12
  • Sound unit economics and resilient revenue models matter more than expansion that creates locations without sustainable operating value. 25:43

What makes a fitness business durable?

Durability starts with separating lasting behavior from a moment in the cycle. Fitness participation now spans more than one channel, with home workouts remaining elevated while visits to gyms and boutique studios also remain strong, according to Canarick. That matters because an investor does not have to assume one format wins and everything else loses.

A durable business can benefit from a broader fitness habit, provided its own customer proposition remains relevant when the market shifts again. 11:31

“And so you put that all together, and when whether COVID gave that behavior a shot in the arm or not, the industry is in as healthy of a place as it has ever been.”

Jon Canarick, Managing Partner, North Castle Partners · 12:07

A business can still stumble when demand moves faster than its operating capacity. Canarick said his Echelon Fitness business went from 30 to 105 to 200 million of revenue in two years, then made the larger point: “It's impossible to manage that growth.” Extraordinary growth can look attractive on a chart while putting tremendous strain underneath it.

For investors, durability therefore includes the organization’s ability to absorb demand without treating an unusual growth period as the permanent baseline. 13:02

“We grew from 30 to 105 to 200 million of revenue in two years.”

Jon Canarick, Managing Partner, North Castle Partners · 13:37

Hurlock emphasized a different side of durability in franchising. He described building infrastructure before chasing rapid expansion, even though “It's the slower way of doing it, it's the more expensive way of doing it, absolutely.” That approach puts support systems ahead of unit count.

The relevant investor filter is not simply whether a concept can sell locations. It is whether the platform underneath those locations can support operators as the network expands, protecting the economics and experience that made expansion appealing in the first place. 41:10

Where does real defensibility come from?

A clever workout alone may offer less protection than founders imagine. Operators often believe their concept is highly differentiated even when nearby alternatives look similar to customers, according to Shane. His sharper point was that “the staying power is in the community you build and the way you build internal community.”

That shifts defensibility away from equipment, color palettes and modality tweaks. Culture, community and execution can be harder to copy because competitors cannot simply purchase them and install them in another storefront. 29:57

“I think what the staying power is in the community you build and the way you build internal community,” Shane said, 30:38

Buyers are showing interest in consumer subscription platforms that combine brand, customer data and a value proposition that can hold up through technological change, according to Bormel. That gives defensibility another layer. A fitness business becomes more interesting when it owns a meaningful consumer relationship rather than functioning as interchangeable infrastructure.

Brand and proprietary customer understanding can give buyers something they do not already possess, which is a more useful test than simply asking whether the company happens to use the latest technology. 14:16

“So for example, it's the platforms that have a brand, have the customer's data, and have a unique value proposition that isn't going anywhere in the age of AI,” Bormel said, 15:00

Why does operator fit matter before capital?

Capital cannot compensate for a mismatch between the opportunity and the people running it. Coletta explained fundraising as a search for “aligned conviction,” where the right investor already shares some version of the founder’s worldview. He also said the founder has to provide evidence not only for the product, but for the team’s unique ability to realize that vision.

Operator fit works both ways: investors need conviction in management, while operators need capital partners whose mandate and thinking actually fit the business. 36:12

“Your job is to find them, give them enough evidence to strengthen that conviction and not only what the product, but your ability to you can uniquely realize that vision is,” Coletta said, 36:45

That operator question gets especially concrete in franchising. His company is looking for “great operators” who can work with a support organization rather than simply adding as many franchisees as possible, according to Hurlock. It is a useful distinction for investors evaluating a growth story.

Selling units can generate momentum, but the quality of the people operating those units influences execution on the ground. A scalable system still depends on operators capable of turning standards, programming and infrastructure into a consistent customer experience. 43:28

“We're just looking for great operators, individuals that are looking for a team that's willing to support them, bend over backwards and make sure they're successful in whatever they do in life and the future opportunities,” Hurlock said, 43:47

How does the business model change the investment case?

Business model matters because demand does not automatically become attractive economics. Shane said Yoga Joint’s appeal to him included “scalable unit level economics.” He also described how urban and suburban locations carry different rents, upside and real estate requirements, which means the same concept can behave differently across markets.

Investors need a model that works under realistic local conditions, not merely a category with strong consumer interest. Site economics, operating costs and repeatability ultimately determine whether expansion creates value or simply creates more locations. 25:43

“I think it makes it investable, scalable unit level economics,” Shane said, 25:48

Diversification offers another model, but it brings a different thesis. Hurlock said Paddle Sweat was designed around more than paddle courts, adding reformer Pilates and contrast offerings to widen its audience, use real estate more fully and create incremental revenue. That is a different bet from the focused boutique studio.

Neither structure is automatically superior. The investment question is whether the additional revenue streams reinforce the core economics or create complexity that the organization then has to manage. 18:08

The way customers pay can also draw private equity interest. Bormel said buyers look at other deals for clues: “private equity is interested in businesses with several means of paying for” products. That suggests a broader business-model filter than headline revenue alone.

Investors can care about how resilient the revenue engine is, how customers access the product and whether the company can support multiple pathways without losing the clarity of its core proposition. 19:43

“But we tell them, hey, look, the private equity is interested in businesses with several means of paying for paying for products and,” Bormel said, 20:34

What operators are doing

Yoga Joint offers a useful example of testing a model rather than assuming geographic portability. Shane said he finds it compelling to take a suburban brand and prove it in an urban market, reversing the more familiar boutique fitness pattern. He also added that every opening still demands diligence, local community building and internal culture.

In investor terms, expansion becomes evidence when an operator can reproduce the experience under a different cost structure, not when management simply plants another flag on a map. 17:27

Fitura Brands is taking another route. Hurlock added that the company built infrastructure before pushing aggressively into rollout, saying, “we've built this plane, we've put in every possible layer of infrastructure we can in the most sustainable way.” That is deliberately different from growth at any cost.

The investor-relevant idea is straightforward: infrastructure can make growth more credible when it demonstrates that the organization has thought beyond selling the next unit and built support around the operators expected to deliver it. 41:10

“We went out, we raised capital, 12 months back, we've built this plane, we've put in every possible layer of infrastructure we can in the most sustainable way,” Hurlock said, 41:23

Vero illustrates operator fit from a very different corner of health and wellness. Coletta said the company chose to pursue further clinical validation rather than immediately scale direct to consumer, despite investor interest in moving faster. That example pushes against the idea that speed always makes a company more investable.

Sometimes management’s willingness to protect the premise of the business matters more. The operator has to know which milestones strengthen the company’s long-term case and which forms of acceleration could weaken it. 29:40

What should matter before anyone talks about a transaction?

The strongest pre-transaction filter is whether the business gives a buyer a reason to believe tomorrow will be worth more than today. Market transactions act as signals about where private equity and strategic buyers want to deploy capital. He also pointed out that founders can study what buyers found enticing and use those signals when thinking about their own strategy.

That does not mean copying the latest deal. It means understanding which underlying attributes attracted capital and asking whether those attributes genuinely exist in the business. 19:43

The final filter is alignment around what the company should become. Bormel pointed out that owners may care about preserving the brand, supporting employees or remaining involved after a transaction. Those priorities change which capital partners make sense.

Our read: Before taking private equity, agree on where growth should come from and what the deal could change about the way you run the business. A check won't settle a disagreement about either.

Explore the Capital and M&A topic hub for more source-backed conversations.

Listen to the full conversation

Jon Canarick, North Castle Partners, on Curves, Equinox, and GLP-1s in Fitness

Jon Canarick · 48 min

Play the episode

Frequently asked questions

What does private equity look for in a fitness company?

Bormel recalled that attractive consumer subscription platforms can combine a brand, customer data and a unique value proposition that remains relevant as technology changes. That frames the core filters well: investors need reasons to believe the customer relationship and business model have value that competitors or new technology cannot easily erase. 14:16

Why are unit economics important to fitness investors?

Shane recalled that scalable unit-level economics help make a fitness concept investable. A popular workout is not enough if new locations cannot reproduce attractive economics under real rents and operating costs. Investors need evidence that expansion can extend the underlying business model rather than simply add more expensive locations to manage. 25:43

What makes a fitness brand defensible?

Shane said surface-level differentiation can be misleading because studios can use different machines, colors or workout variations without becoming fundamentally distinct. He said staying power comes from community, which points toward a stronger moat: relationships and internal culture that competitors cannot reproduce simply by copying a modality. 29:57

How important is the founder or management team to investors?

Coletta stressed that fundraising ultimately comes down to aligned conviction and evidence that the founder can uniquely realize the vision. That makes management part of the investment thesis itself. Investors are not evaluating only the market opportunity or product. They are also assessing whether this particular team can turn that opportunity into an enduring company. 36:12

More in Capital and M&A ↗

From Eric, every week

The conversations worth your time, in one email.