New: The State of Fitness, Q2 2026. Get the free report
Franchising

Adapting a yoga studio to New York: Adam Shane

Yoga Joint adapted its Florida studio model to Manhattan by keeping its classes and hospitality intact while adjusting to higher costs, tighter space and more competition. Adam Shane’s challenge is not to reinvent that product for Manhattan. It is to make the experience work inside New York’s tougher cost structure, real estate constraints, crowded fitness market and battle for attention.

Adam Shane
Adam Shane, Owner, Yoga Joint New York

Key takeaways

  • Yoga Joint brought New York an immersive mix of yoga, strength, music, lighting and community rather than a conventional yoga experience. 3:53
  • New York changes the cost structure and real estate choices, but Shane says it should not reduce the diligence behind opening. 16:27
  • For Shane, the customer experience starts before class, including transportation access, building entry and the physical path into the studio. 20:20
  • A differentiated workout is not enough. Shane sees internal culture, hospitality and community as the more durable sources of staying power. 29:57

Bring the product, adapt the operating model

The New York move reverses the familiar expansion path in boutique fitness, according to Shane. Instead of taking an urban concept into the suburbs, Yoga Joint is bringing a suburban model into a major urban market. That makes New York a test of whether the underlying experience travels when the economics, real estate and competitive environment change.

The product may arrive intact, but the assumptions around it cannot. 16:27

“But from a personal standpoint, I think it's really exciting to take a suburban brand and prove the urban model.”

Adam Shane, Franchise Owner and Managing Director, Yoga Joint NY · 16:35

What travels is a format Shane described as a blend of lower impact exercise and high energy presentation. Yoga Joint combines an immersive setting with music, dark lighting and instructor guidance, rather than treating yoga as a quiet, visually exposed experience, according to Shane. That choice also addresses a practical customer problem: beginners can feel intimidated when they believe everybody else can see whether they know the poses. 4:53

“And it's all delivered in, what I would call like a fully immersive setting with dark lights, fun music, instructor, guiding you through the workout.”

Adam Shane, Franchise Owner and Managing Director, Yoga Joint NY · 4:54

The class mix also reaches beyond a conventional yoga proposition. The schedule is split between a cardio and strength format and a vinyasa-inspired flow format, according to Shane. That gives Yoga Joint room to serve people who want different experiences under the same brand, while still keeping yoga principles at the center of the concept.

For New York, that breadth becomes part of the value proposition rather than a reason to keep adding new modalities. 6:59

New York starts with the trip to the front door

A strong class does not rescue bad real estate. The first job is understanding the customer and locating near where that customer lives and works, according to Shane. In New York, vertical density can make those patterns easier to identify, but a viable site still has to satisfy the physical requirements of the operation.

Real estate therefore becomes part customer analysis, part engineering problem and part hospitality decision. 19:20

“The number one thing that you need to do is understand your customer and you need to know where they live and work,” Shane said, 19:39

That hospitality piece extends outside the studio. Shane said proximity to public transportation and the way customers enter the building belong in the experience equation. A cheaper location can carry a hidden cost if customers have an awkward journey before class even starts.

His point matters because a lease locks an operator into those small decisions for a long time, while members encounter them on every visit. 23:13

“I'm talking about, how close you are to the subway, how close you are to public transportation, and, what the entry experience is,” Shane said, 20:58

New York also changes the financial side of the equation. Shane said the effort required to build culture, work with local businesses and establish a community should remain rigorous wherever a studio opens. What changes is the cost structure.

That distinction keeps the expansion logic grounded: New York does not earn a shortcut because it is New York, and higher costs make disciplined execution more important rather than less. 17:27

Big rooms make community part of the model

Yoga Joint is also resisting one apparent pressure of expensive urban real estate. The brand wants bigger spaces because he sees physical scale as a way to create a different kind of group energy, Shane said. His argument is not that small studios cannot create community.

It is that gathering more people around the same experience can make community more tangible, provided the operator backs it with strong hospitality. 15:39

“But when you have 10 people in a room versus 55, there's just this different spirit and energy that room creates that is magical when done at the highest possible level of hospitality,” Shane said, 15:42

Shane said successful execution comes down to people, product and hospitality, with consistency tying them together. A beautiful studio and distinctive class format can attract attention, but they cannot substitute for a team that delivers the experience repeatedly.

For a new market, culture therefore becomes operating infrastructure. The customer-facing community depends first on the internal one. 29:57

“Going back to what makes this business most successful is the people, the product, and the hospitality,” Shane said, 27:09

Differentiation is less powerful than operators think

The crowded New York market forced another useful lesson. Fitness operators routinely overestimate how different their concepts look to customers, Shane said. A wall color, machine or variation on a modality may feel meaningful from inside the business without creating durable separation outside it.

That shifts the strategic question away from how unusual the workout appears and toward whether customers develop a reason to stay connected to the brand. 29:57

“Everyone thinks their product is different, not necessarily better or worse, but different,” Shane said, 30:05

For Shane, that durable advantage circles back to community. Staying power comes from the community a studio builds and how it develops that community internally, Shane said. That is an especially important lesson when customers have many products competing for their attention.

Yoga Joint can bring its format from Florida, but New York still requires relationships with local customers, businesses and talent that cannot simply be imported. 17:27

“I think what the staying power is in the community you build and the way you build internal community,” Shane said, 30:38

The next local problem is earning attention

Before customers can experience the room, they have to notice the brand. He is working to understand digital awareness and acknowledged that differentiating Yoga Joint online is difficult, Shane said. That is a revealing local learning curve: an immersive physical experience does not automatically translate onto a phone screen.

The operating team has to communicate what makes the brand useful without assuming the product will explain itself. 42:30

The larger lesson is straightforward. Shane added that the New York team is being patient about finding people who can establish the local culture. Yoga Joint may have a blueprint, but execution still belongs to the people on the ground.

That is what adapting a brand really looks like here: protect the experience that made it work elsewhere, then do the local work around real estate, talent, community and awareness instead of assuming a proven concept will carry itself. 40:29

Explore the Franchising topic hub for more source-backed conversations.

Listen to the full conversation

Adam Shane (Yoga Joint New York) on Why a Suburban Fitness Brand Is Betting on Manhattan

Adam Shane · 48 min

Play the episode

Frequently asked questions

What makes Yoga Joint different from a traditional yoga studio?

Shane added that the darker room can lower the intimidation factor for beginners because participants face forward rather than worrying about who is watching them. Music and lighting also make the environment more immersive, while the instruction is intended to remain challenging for experienced participants and approachable for newcomers. 6:59

Why did Yoga Joint expand to New York?

Shane described that he was excited by the opportunity to prove an urban model for a brand that had already worked in suburban markets. He said direction as the reverse of the usual boutique fitness path, where an urban concept later has to demonstrate that its economics work in the suburbs. 16:27

How does Yoga Joint choose locations in New York?

Shane pointed out that understanding where the target customer lives and works comes first. He also pointed out that site selection must account for the physical requirements of the studio and the surrounding building. His broader principle is simple: locate as close to the customer as the real estate allows. 19:20

What did Yoga Joint have to learn about the New York fitness market?

Shane recalled that operators should not assume surface-level product differences create lasting differentiation. In a crowded market, he sees community and internal culture as more important sources of staying power. Yoga Joint therefore has to establish local relationships and consistent hospitality, not simply transplant its Florida format. 29:57

More in Franchising ↗

From Eric, every week

The conversations worth your time, in one email.