New: The State of Fitness, Q2 2026. Get the free report
Gym Operators

Make exercise easier to repeat: Dr. Heather McKee

Exercise gets easier to repeat when the first step is small, enjoyable and realistic on a busy day. It is an action small enough to repeat, enjoyable enough to want again and realistic enough to fit an ordinary day. McKee's argument is that those repetitions can build the habit that eventually carries more of the load than motivation.

Dr. Heather McKee
Dr. Heather McKee, Behavioral scientist and Motivation Science Advisor, Myzone

Key takeaways

  • Start with an action small enough to complete instead of waiting for motivation to arrive. 2:41
  • Match exercise difficulty to current competence so early sessions create progress rather than discouragement. 13:44
  • Treat enjoyment as part of habit formation because people need reasons to choose the activity again. 12:02
  • Expect missed days and build a routine that makes returning feel normal. 6:40

Start with action, not motivation

Motivation changes with sleep, stress, time and everyday circumstances, so waiting until you feel motivated makes action unnecessarily fragile, according to McKee. Starting can itself create confidence and positive feedback, she said. That shifts the practical question from "How do I get more motivated?" to "What can I do now that feels easy enough to complete?" The first move should lower the barrier instead of demanding a heroic effort.

“Because the fastest route to motivation is make that first action really small, make it easy enough to complete.”

Dr. Heather McKee, Motivation Science Advisor, Myzone · 3:32

That also means planning for normal life rather than an imaginary future version of yourself. People often make plans when they can picture themselves with more time, energy and discipline than they will reliably have, according to McKee. A useful starting behavior needs to survive the crowded workday, competing commitments and low energy. If the plan only works on your best day, it asks motivation to do too much work.

“We need to design a useful version for the ordinary Tuesday when you're up against it with work or other commitments and your time is limited.”

Dr. Heather McKee, Motivation Science Advisor, Myzone · 6:02

Match the challenge to where you are

Making exercise easier does not mean removing challenge. Competence is the confidence and ability to execute a task, and people need enough challenge to feel progress without pushing so far that the task feels beyond them, according to McKee. That distinction matters at the beginning. A workout can look productive on paper while giving someone an immediate lesson that exercise is something they cannot do well.

“And so we need to feel, first of all, that we are at an adequate level of challenge that we're learning, but yet not too much that actually it's beyond our capabilities,” McKee said, 13:59

For someone carrying negative associations with exercise, McKee emphasized the value of simple tasks they can master quickly. Early success gives the person evidence that movement belongs within their capabilities. Instead of treating an easier starting point as a compromise, her argument treats it as part of building the behavior itself. The appropriate baseline depends on the person, which is why the same opening challenge will not work equally well for everyone.

“So for those people, it's really important to give them simple tasks that they can feel really good at and they feel like they can master like almost immediately,” McKee said, 14:30

Enjoyment is part of the behavior strategy

Enjoyment can sound secondary when people focus on intensity, but McKee said affect includes enjoyment and the perceived difficulty of exercise. Starting someone with exercise that feels punishing can reduce their sense of competence and control. That creates a basic behavioral problem: even when an activity looks demanding enough to promise results, the experience may give the person fewer reasons to choose it again when motivation is lower. 11:29

People engage more with exercise they enjoy and with activities that give them a sense of progress and mastery, according to McKee. Enjoyment, in that framing, is not a reward saved for after the serious work. It helps make repetition more likely. That suggests a different way to judge a starting workout: not simply by how hard it was, but by whether the experience created enough success to make another session appealing.

“And actually, it's the exercise that people enjoy and the exercise that people feel a sense of progress and a sense of mastery that actually they're going to engage with more and more,” McKee said, 12:02

Repetition gives habits a chance to take over

McKee said repetitions form habits, which is why simpler actions matter beyond the first workout. Keeping the behavior small creates more opportunities to practice showing up instead of repeatedly testing whether enthusiasm is high enough. Over time, her argument shifts the source of consistency. Motivation may help someone begin, but the aim is to build a behavior that becomes less dependent on needing the right feeling before every session.

“And that is why we want to set people up with habits, because habit is low at the start because you haven't got that many repetitions, and it's repetitions that form habit,” McKee said, 15:27

McKee said calling something an experiment makes failure easier to tolerate and supports a longer view of habit formation. Try an activity, notice whether it feels manageable and enjoyable, then adjust. That approach gives people room to discover what they can actually repeat rather than locking themselves into a demanding plan because it seemed ideal at the moment they started.

“I love the word experiment because it allows people to fail easily,” McKee said, 15:45

Build for the wobble, not a perfect streak

A repeatable exercise habit also needs room for missed days and disrupted routines. McKee said people can feel shame after a wobble, which can make returning harder. Treating setbacks as expected changes the task from preserving a flawless streak to restarting the behavior.

That matters because real life will eventually interfere. A habit with some flexibility has a better chance of remaining usable when schedules, energy or circumstances stop cooperating. 7:15

McKee said habits should not become rigid regimes that leave no room for ordinary life. Her broader argument comes back to freedom, capability and repetition: choose an action that fits, keep the difficulty appropriate, find movement you can enjoy and make returning normal after disruption. The practical standard is straightforward.

The best starting behavior is not the one that proves how committed you are today. It is the one you can realistically come back to. 3:32

Explore the Gym operators topic hub for more source-backed conversations.

Listen to the full conversation

Dr. Heather McKee, PhD Behavioral Scientist, on Habit Formation and Fitness Motivation

Dr. Heather McKee · 50 min

Play the episode

Frequently asked questions

How do you start an exercise habit when you have no motivation?

Start by shrinking the first action. McKee said action can create confidence and positive feedback rather than merely waiting for motivation to supply them. The practical goal is to make the first behavior easy enough to complete, then use that successful experience as something you can build on. 2:41

Why does enjoyment matter for sticking with exercise?

McKee added that exercise people enjoy, especially when it also provides progress and mastery, is something they are more likely to engage with repeatedly. That makes enjoyment behaviorally useful rather than optional. An activity that feels rewarding and manageable gives a person a stronger reason to choose it again. 12:02

Should beginners start with high intensity exercise?

Not automatically. McKee added that starting with difficult, high intensity exercise can make people feel less competent and less in control. Her argument favors matching difficulty to the person's starting capability, allowing enough challenge for progress without making the experience so demanding that continuing becomes unattractive. 11:39

How does repetition turn exercise into a habit?

McKee described that repetitions form habits, so keeping the behavior small can make repeated practice more achievable. As those repetitions accumulate, the routine can rely less on fluctuating motivation. That is why a modest action repeated consistently can be more useful for habit formation than repeatedly attempting an ambitious plan. 15:27

More in Gym Operators ↗

From Eric, every week

The conversations worth your time, in one email.