New: The State of Fitness, Q2 2026. Get the free report
Franchising

How fitness franchises scale

Fitness franchises scale by proving one location works, teaching new operators how to repeat it and supporting them as they adapt locally. The operators in these conversations take different routes, but the useful pattern is clear: prove the store, standardize what drives the member experience, leave room for local execution, and build franchisor support before aggressive expansion. Scale means reproducing a healthy operating business in another market with another operator, not selling more licenses.

Will Bartholomew
Will Bartholomew, Founder and CEO, D1 Training

Key takeaways

  • Prove the business can run without the founder before asking franchisees to reproduce it. 9:16
  • Standardize the member journey, coaching system and operating routines, not just the brand look and workout. 12:20
  • Local adaptation belongs in real estate, community building and market execution, inside clear brand guardrails. 19:48
  • Franchisors owe operators infrastructure, training, real estate discipline and ongoing performance support after opening. 18:48

What has to work before a fitness concept can scale?

The first test is whether a location can run without its founder acting as the operating system. An early franchising adviser told him, "Never start scaling anything until you've scaled it yourself." He then opened locations far enough away that he could not simply jump in and solve every problem personally, according to Bartholomew. That forced D1 to create processes for remote management and to figure out what parts of the founder's approach could actually be transferred to another team. 9:54

“He said, Never start scaling anything until you've scaled it yourself.”

Will Bartholomew, Founder, D1 Training · 9:53

Hull emphasized a second requirement: "Unit level economics is super important." His view of Fitstop's expansion is that growth should follow healthy stores rather than license sales becoming the goal itself. That distinction matters because franchising can make top-line expansion look fast even while individual operators struggle. A scalable model therefore needs a store-level economic engine and a product members will keep buying, not just an effective franchise sales organization. 1:25

“Unit level economics is super important,” Hull said, 2:12

Hurlock argued for building infrastructure before pushing hard on development. He explained, "We've built this plane, we've put in every possible layer of infrastructure we can in the most sustainable way." That approach is deliberately slower and more expensive than filling organizational gaps after franchisees arrive. The implication is pretty straightforward: the franchisee should not become the test subject for unfinished systems, weak support, or an operating model the franchisor has not yet learned to deliver consistently. 0:20

What should the store operation standardize?

Fitstop starts with the training product. The business supports coaches through an academy where programming is distributed, online coursework before coaching, in-person accreditation and continuing development, according to Hull. That turns programming from founder knowledge into an operating system another location can execute. The standard is not simply what exercises appear on the floor. It includes how coaches learn the product, how they communicate it and how the network keeps improving execution over time. 18:48

The member journey needs the same treatment. Hull emphasized, "The first contact point is always going to be that lead call." Fitstop wants that conversation to uncover the prospect's goal, then connect the person to the training experience and ongoing adherence. This is where store operations and brand positioning meet. A franchise cannot reproduce a promise merely through logos and equipment. The everyday behaviors around leads, onboarding, coaching and member relationships have to become teachable routines. 13:30

“The first contact point is always going to be that lead call,” Hull said, 13:30

Bartholomew described a similar operating discipline at D1 through assessment and goal setting. He explained, "Everything starts with an assessment." Coaches establish a baseline and discuss goals before directing an athlete toward the appropriate training path. The modalities differ from Fitstop, but the scaling principle travels well: define the critical moments in the customer journey and make their execution repeatable. A location should not have to reinvent how a prospect becomes an engaged member every time a new manager takes over. 23:26

“And everything starts with an assessment.”

Will Bartholomew, Founder, D1 Training · 23:26

Where should local adaptation begin?

Standardization should not turn every market into a copy-and-paste exercise. Shane clarified, "The number one thing that you need to do is understand your customer and you need to know where they live and work." For Yoga Joint's move from suburban Florida toward New York, local realities include density, customer movement and the physical requirements of each site. The brand can preserve its class experience while adapting the real estate decision to how customers actually navigate a particular market. 19:39

“The number one thing that you need to do is understand your customer and you need to know where they live and work,” Shane said, 19:39

Market adaptation does not lower the operating bar, according to Shane. He said each opening needs comparable diligence around internal culture, the local team, external community and nearby businesses. Costs can change sharply from one market to another, but the work of proving the service still happens store by store. That is a useful boundary for franchise systems: localize site selection, community building and market execution without casually changing the elements that define why customers chose the brand. 17:27

Fitstop builds local flexibility into a broader plan rather than leaving owners to improvise. Studios create an annual game plan around the national calendar, then add local competitions, training opportunities, social events and community activity, according to Hull. That gives operators room to respond to what is happening in their market while keeping the larger brand cadence intact. Local adaptation works best when the franchisor defines the guardrails and the operator decides how to bring them to life locally. 19:48

What operators are doing

Fitstop is combining a centralized training product with systems around the business. Hull said the training product remains the core element, while the surrounding business systems are what make replication possible. That division is important. The workout may attract the member, but expansion also demands coach education, annual planning, marketing and operating support. Fitstop's model treats those pieces as infrastructure around the product rather than expecting each owner to assemble a local operating system independently. 12:20

Yoga Joint provides a different example because Shane is testing how a suburban concept translates into an urban market. He clarified, "There's just a difference in the cost structure." The underlying work still requires culture, community and disciplined execution, but a Manhattan site cannot be evaluated with the same real estate assumptions as suburban Florida. Yoga Joint's example shows why scalable does not mean identical. A repeatable concept still has to survive the economics and customer behavior of the market it enters. 18:27

“There's just a difference in the cost structure,” Shane said, 18:27

D1 took yet another route by accumulating operating experience before packaging the model for franchisees. Bartholomew said the company revisited lead generation, what consumers wanted to buy and other business practices before franchising. He described the eventual franchise package as the product of years of operating lessons rather than a concept designed primarily for franchise sales. That history matters because documentation becomes much more valuable when it captures solutions tested in real stores, under actual operating pressure. 15:17

What support does a franchisor owe an operator?

A franchisor's job does not end when the playbook is delivered. Hull said Fitstop maintains an operational team with business performance coaches serving as a direct support line for owners. That matters because even a well-built system meets messy situations once it reaches different sites and operators. Training, troubleshooting and performance feedback need owners on both sides. The operator remains accountable for running the store, while the franchisor remains accountable for making the system usable and supporting its proper execution. 20:48

Real estate is one place where that obligation becomes especially concrete. Operators should not have to guess their way through site selection when a franchisor can provide experience and data, Hurlock said. A promising lease can deteriorate quickly when physical constraints reduce useful workout space. As Hurlock put it, "you can't undo a bad lease." Support before signing can therefore matter as much as operational coaching after opening, because some early decisions become extremely difficult to reverse. 25:03

“you can change a lot of things with an operational business, but you can't undo a bad lease,” Hurlock said, 24:40

Support also has to survive geographic expansion. Hull said Fitstop kept its leadership base focused on Australia even while beginning its U.S. effort, because the established market remained the business's heartbeat and needed support. That highlights a tension every expanding franchisor eventually faces: new markets demand leadership attention, but existing operators cannot become yesterday's priority. Sustainable expansion requires adding capacity rather than simply redirecting it from the network that already depends on the franchisor. 3:25

How do you know the model is ready to keep expanding?

The practical test is whether performance comes from the system rather than extraordinary founder effort. Bartholomew said D1 keeps iterating and sharpening its business practices as franchisees use them. That is a better picture of repeatability than pretending the playbook ever becomes finished. A scalable franchise has enough structure to reproduce the experience today and enough feedback loops to improve it tomorrow. Stores become sources of operating intelligence, not merely endpoints for instructions from headquarters. 17:41

There is also a philosophical choice about pace. Hurlock added that building the infrastructure first is "the slower way of doing it, it's the more expensive way of doing it, absolutely." Hull similarly stressed product durability and unit economics over license volume. The useful lesson is not that every brand should grow slowly. It is that growth speed should follow operating readiness. When sales outpace support, site discipline and proven store economics, the franchisor transfers the consequences of that gap to its operators. 0:32

“It's the slower way of doing it, it's the more expensive way of doing it, absolutely,” Hurlock said, 0:32

Explore the Franchising topic hub for more source-backed conversations.

Listen to the full conversation

Will Bartholomew - From Peyton Manning's Teammate to D1 Training Founder

Will Bartholomew · 52 min

Play the episode

Frequently asked questions

What makes a fitness franchise scalable?

Bartholomew added that a founder should prove the model can operate beyond the founder's personal reach before scaling it. The core test is whether processes can reproduce the customer experience and manage the business from afar, rather than relying on one charismatic owner to keep every location working. 10:16

How much freedom should a fitness franchisee have locally?

Hull said Fitstop combines a national plan with room for each studio to build its own game plan. That structure lets an operator respond to local competitions, community events and social opportunities while staying inside a broader brand calendar. Local freedom works best when the franchisor supplies clear operating guardrails. 19:48

Why is real estate so important when scaling a fitness franchise?

Operators must understand where their customers live and work before choosing a site, Shane said. Demographics alone do not finish the job. The location also has to fit the brand's physical requirements and customer journey, including practical access, so market expansion starts with local behavior rather than a generic site template. 19:20

What support should a fitness franchisor provide franchisees?

Hurlock pointed out that franchisors should help operators make informed decisions instead of leaving them to guess, especially in real estate. That principle extends to the operating model: owners need infrastructure and experienced guidance before irreversible commitments. The franchise relationship should transfer proven capability, not simply a name and a set of instructions. 23:40

More in Franchising ↗

From Eric, every week

The conversations worth your time, in one email.